One of Us Is Lying

NBCUniversal

Extras casting for One of Us Is Lying by Sarah Hart Casting

TV Series

One of Us is Lying S2

produced by

NBCUniversal

Services

For the second season of One of Us Is Lying, the brief was clear: elevate the world of Bayview with a more compelling and dynamic background cast.

While we weren’t involved in Season 1, the team was eager to bring fresh energy and a more refined atmosphere to the setting—so the pressure was on to help raise the bar.

We sourced a standout group of artists who brought the perfect mix of attitude, presence, and polish. Every background performer was carefully selected to match the tone and style of the show, from classroom scenes to high-stakes party sequences.

Working closely with the production and costume departments, we ensured visual cohesion and authenticity across the season—coordinating core background across multi-day shoots and supporting newer talent as they settled confidently into the on-set environment.

The Result: A season that looked and felt elevated from the start—so much so that the producers shared how thrilled they were with the background cast. The feedback was overwhelmingly positive, highlighting how much the ensemble enriched the tone and believability of the world of Bayview.

“Was just talking with the team about how much better the extras are this year, and just wanted to reach out to thank you and your team for all the hard work. Know you got thrown in the deep end right away, and you guys are doing a great job!”

Matt Groesh, Producer

One of Us Is Lying Extras Casting